Meet the Cast


The Mod Musical


Caitlin Kleinschmidt (Red)

Caitlin is returning to the Ghostlight stage once again as Red, the youngest and most innocent character in SHOUT! The Mod Musical. You might recognize her from our 2021 production of All Through the Night, where she played the young teacher, Anne. 


Janice Stern (Yellow)

Janice is thrilled to be making her Ghostlight Theatre debut. Janice spent several years performing at Walt Disney World in various character roles (Fantasmic! Celebrate the Season, SpectroMagic, Disney Dreams Come True). Past credits: Minnie/Teresita (West Side Story) and Betty (Footloose), both with Upstage Productions. At the Winter Park Playhouse (FL), she alternated between cast and crew: I Love You, You’re Perfect Now Change, Sugar Babies, Pete and Keely, and was a former Ambassador for The Orlando Shakespeare Theatre. She holds a BA in Theatre from SUNY Fredonia and is a wife and mother to two energetic kids.


Jill Anderson (Green)

Jill is so excited to be working on her 11th consecutive musical at the Ghostlight Theatre! Jill has been performing for 15 years, having performed in over 30 local productions. Some of her past roles include Belle (Beauty and the Beast), Sally Bowles (Cabaret), Queen Gertrude (Hamlet), and Sister Mary Leo (Nunsense 1&2). She is a proud graduate of the University at Buffalo with a BFA in Music Theatre and a minor in education. This past May, Jill also earned her M.S Ed in Theatre Education from Niagara University. Beyond performing in musicals and Shakespeare dramas, Jill also has a passion for choreography and directing. At UB, she had the great honor of directing The Cat in The Hat, which was the first children's theatre production for young audiences performed through the university’s Theatre and Dance Department. Her passion for theatre education began seven years ago, and since then, she has directed and/or choreographed over 16 productions for performers of all ages. Her work on Bring it On! was nominated for “Best Choreography of a Musical” through BroadwayWorld’s Regional Awards in 2019, and her production of Rock of Ages won Best Musical the year prior. Other awards include a TANY for her portrayal of Penny in Hairspray and a Tony Award nomination for the 2022 Educator of the Year Award. Currently, Jill is working as the Theatre and Dance teacher at Sacred Heart Academy. In her free time, she has the privilege of teaching singing lessons at Matt’s Music in North Tonawanda, adjudicates for Shea's Kenny Awards, and snuggles with her cat, Boots.

Jessica Smith (Blue)

Jessica Smith has been a vocal student at Matt's Music for nearly three years, during which she has participated in Matt's Music singing events and has performed songs and backup vocals at gigs with other local musicians. With a career in technology, she recently took over the role of Stage Manager at Niagara Wheatfield School District, responsible for sound, lighting, and advising the stage crew (Addams Family [2022], Moana Jr [2022], and 13 Ways to Screw Up Your College Interview [2022]). She is so excited to make her own musical theater debut as Blue Girl! She would like to thank the Starry Night Theater Directors and her fellow cast for making her first musical theater performance a wonderful experience!


Julie Senko (Gwendolyn Holmes)

Julie has been an active member of the company since 1986. She started as a chorus girl in Oklahoma! Since then, she has been involved with every show. Some musicals you may have spotted her in over the years include Fiddler on the Roof, The Music Man, Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, Pippin, Godspell, Oliver, and Big River. When not on stage, Julie has been seen constructing sets, costuming, running lights and sound, and helping to run the house. She is secretary of Starry Night Theatre Inc.'s board and a past recipient of the Stephen Holesko Memorial Award. She is currently our head costumer, teaches the children's acting class, and is a member of our Creative Committee where she is in charge of house management.